Call Now
855-712-6289

December Is About 10% Slower. That’s Still 90% of Your Buyers.

The dealer who doesn’t pause December advertising wins. Sitting out the month hands roughly nine out of ten December Subprime Shoppers, and every fresh bankruptcy that still files, to the store that stayed live.

Every year around now, dealers start talking like December is on pause. It isn’t. The dealer who doesn’t pause December advertising wins.

In my experience running Daily Subprime Triggers since 2005, December Subprime Shopper volume usually runs about 10% lower than a normal month. Ten percent. Not 50. Not 100.

Do the math the other way: about 90% of those buyers are still shopping.

That’s the whole argument in one number. If you shut the lights off, you aren’t protecting a slow month. You’re handing most of the Subprime Shoppers who still need a car before year-end to the competitor who stayed live. The industry numbers say the month is far from dead.

What the market actually did last December

Cox Automotive put December 2025 new-vehicle volume at about 1.46 million units, and later said that forecast was spot on. That’s roughly 7% above the average month for the year, and about 13% above November. Used retail came in at 1.34 million, up 2% from November. Cox called it "unusual growth during a month that typically sees a slowdown."

Retail new sales were softer than the headline, and fleet helped the total. Used retail is the closer comparison for most of our dealers, and that market still beat November.

Bankruptcies didn’t take December off either. Epiq AACER, as reported by the American Bankruptcy Institute, counted 45,935 total filings in December 2025, including 43,387 consumer filings (27,150 Chapter 7s and 16,147 Chapter 13s). That’s only about 2 to 3% below the average month, and total filings were up 20% from December 2024.

So the broad market kept moving. Subprime Shoppers slowed a little in my data, about 10%, and bankruptcies barely dipped at all. Neither one stopped.

90% still need a car in December

A Subprime Shopper who triggers on December 12th isn’t waiting for January 2nd. Their car quit, their commute changed, or their financing application is already in. Same with someone who files or gets a discharge mid-month. They need transportation now.

I’ve mailed fresh bankruptcies since 1989 and Triggers since 2005. I’ve never seen a December with zero Subprime Shoppers, and I’ve never seen a December with no filings. A 10% dip is real. Treating it like a shutdown is not.

You’re not paused. You’re just not in the mail.

Here’s the part that makes the "wait until January" plan even weaker.

Daily Subprime Triggers only mail Subprime Shoppers in your market who are actively applying for auto financing, a credit inquiry. No shoppers means no mail. No mail means no charge. Your funds stay on account and roll into January.

Triggers now include email at no extra charge. Every Trigger we mail that has an email on file, or one we can append, also gets the same offer in the inbox. The mail piece still does the heavy lifting. The email is a second touch, at no added cost, while that shopper is still deciding where to go.

Fresh Bankruptcy works the same way. No new filings or discharges in your area means we don’t spend. That money waits for January too.

So sitting out December doesn’t save budget. The budget only spends when real buyers show up. What sitting out does is unsubscribe you from December’s Subprime Shoppers and December’s fresh bankruptcies while someone else stays in front of them.

And that someone else can lock the market

Triggers come with market exclusivity. When a dealer in your area turns them on, that market is theirs. If your competitor uses December to claim it, "after the first of the year" can turn into "that market is already taken."

The January excuse often isn’t a budget decision. It’s a competitor problem you haven’t priced yet.

What it looks like when you stay in

Don Bulluck Chevrolet in Rocky Mount, NC spent $4,100 the first month and reported over $22,000 in gross. Every piece carries the EasyDrive Card, so the Subprime Shopper has a clear reason to come to that store, not the one down the street.

That’s the point of staying live: when roughly 90% of the buyers are still out there, you want your store on the piece they open.

See the 90% in your market before you decide

I’m not asking you to take the national numbers on faith. I’ll run a free count of the Subprime Shoppers and recent bankruptcies in your area so you can see what December looks like where you sell. If the volume isn’t there, you’ve lost nothing. If it is, you’ll know exactly what a 10% dip still leaves on the table.

Call or text me at (330) 685-5664, or book a quick 15-minute Google Meet.

Ten percent slower is still ninety percent of your buyers. The dealer who doesn’t pause December advertising wins those deals. Don’t gift that share to the store that stayed live.

Sources: Cox Automotive, "Cox Automotive Forecast" (updated Jan 7, 2026), https://www.coxautoinc.com/insights/cox-automotive-forecast-dec-2025-u-s-auto-sales-forecast/; Cox Automotive, "Used-Vehicle Retail Sales Climb in December, Defying Seasonal Slowdown" (Jan 16, 2026), https://www.coxautoinc.com/insights/used-retail-vehicle-sales-december-2025/; Epiq AACER / American Bankruptcy Institute, "Total Bankruptcy Filings Increase 11 Percent in Calendar Year 2025" (Jan 6, 2026), https://www.abi.org/node/1001621. December Subprime Shopper volume (about 10% lower) is Denny Long’s first-hand Triggers experience since 2005, not a published industry index.

$22,000 in Gross From a $4,100 Test

$22,000 in Gross From a $4,100 Test

A Subprime Shopper walked into Don Bulluck Chevrolet after getting our mail. Oshae Goddard worked his deal, found him a lender and got him approved. When he came back to pick up his new ride, he brought his girlfriend along. She had prime credit. Before they left,...

read more
The Special Finance Deal That Saved a Life

The Special Finance Deal That Saved a Life

Ryan Wood does not stay late. That is not a knock on Ryan. He is the General Sales Manager at Don Bulluck Chevrolet in Rocky Mount, North Carolina, and he works long hours. He works hard during every one of them. But when the store closes at 7:00 PM, Ryan goes home....

read more
The 750 Customers Nobody Called Back

The 750 Customers Nobody Called Back

Every month, World Hyundai and World Kia, two Chicago-area stores, welcome 2,000 people through their doors. They sell a combined 450 to 550 cars. What happened to the other roughly 1,500 people who walked in, talked to a salesperson, and left without buying? For most...

read more